Which Amazon Echo Device Should I Buy?

We're spelling out all the differences between Amazon's Echo line-up

Echo Show
Photo from Amazon

Originally launched in 2015, Amazon’s cylindrical, Internet-connected speaker called Echo introduced millions to the future concept of a smart home. Fast forward a few years and Amazon’s expanded Echo line now includes four devices, each of which attempts to add a functionality to your life you never knew you were missing. The concept of a smart home didn’t originate with Amazon’s Echo devices, but they have helped mainstream the idea that speaking to a device in your house is less Hollywood and more a glimpse into a better, more connected tomorrow. Need a little help deciding which one you should spring for? Below, we spell out the differences between each one, so you'll have no problem finding the one that's perfect for you.

Rightly considered part of the evolution of Amazon’s Echo line, the Show does exactly as its name says. It “shows” you the very same information as the original Echo would speak. Your daily flash briefing is no longer just spoken word. It’s now shown to you via video alongside YouTube clips and a visual look at the day’s forecast. Like the rest of the Echo series, the Show remains completely hands-free, but the built-in seven-inch display allows a slew of extras, including video calling to other Show owners or voice-dialing to cylindrical Echo and Echo Dot users. The Show will also connect with compatible smart home cameras such as Arlo or Ring and show you your front door or monitor the baby’s room.

The dual two-inch speakers provide “expansive, stereo-sound” with rich bass for listening to your streaming music favorites across Amazon Music, Spotify, Pandora and more. Lyrics from your music will even flash across the display as you’re listening to one of the aforementioned music networks. Past audio, the inclusion of Bluetooth partners nicely with dual-band Wi-Fi support on both 2.4 and 5GHz networks for a device that’s compatible with hundreds of smart home devices. Weighing 41 ounces, the Show is best featured on a nightstand, desktop or even a kitchen counter within the reach of its six-foot long AC power cable.

With eight microphones and noise-cancelation, the Show handily "hears" from any direction courtesy of far-field voice recognition and beamforming technology. The addition of thousands of “Amazon Skills” or new features comes often from both Amazon and third-party developers, which means you can discover new possibilities with Amazon’s Echo line almost daily.

Amazon’s Echo Look is unique and is very much a niche product that’s designed for fashion-conscious users who have trouble deciding their daily outfits. Before diving into the Look’s intended use case, it’s worth noting that it does include a (mostly) full set of standard Echo options such as news, weather, traffic, control of other smart home devices and music. Past its basic skills, the built-in five-megapixel camera and Intel RealSense SR300 depth-sensing technology camera are where the magic truly lies and they work together with the downloadable Android and iOS Amazon Look app. Wall-mountable, the Look also includes a built-in array of microphones and speaker for the more traditional Echo features.

Amazon bills the Look as a “connected fashion consultant” and it’s not far from the truth since the Look allows users to snap pictures of themselves in various outfits. Once an image is captured, the Look software will automatically blur the background in the image to make each outfit the dedicated focus. Once that process happens, machine learning takes over and helps advise you through a feature called “Style Check” to offer advice on what you should (and should not) wear.

As a style assistant, the Look succeeds with add-ons that include taking a short video so you can see your outfit choice from every angle. This 360-degree view of your outfit can even be used to create a personal lookbook that can you refer to later for fashion reference. Ultimately, there’s little debate the Look is a niche product that’s heavily focused on fashion-first users and won’t appeal to the same masses as the other models in the Echo line. However, if you’re eager for a “friend” that will help you look your best, the Look is a unique take on having your very own personal shopper.

The baby of Amazon’s Echo line, the 1.6-inch tall Echo Dot is best described as the top section of the full-sized Echo with one speaker. Equally as smart, the always-on Echo Dot connects to the very same cloud and controls the same connected devices at a fraction of the price. The largest difference between the two devices is the full-sized speaker that’s missing on the Dot. Instead, Amazon is counting on you hooking the Dot up to your existing audio setup via Bluetooth or audio-out cable (3.5mm) and utilizing Alexa with your existing speaker set.

The built-in speaker is great for reading news, setting alarms and listening to audiobooks from Audible, but it lacks the bass or acoustic depth you’ll find on the larger Echo. Ideally, the Dot will be placed centrally in a house, perhaps in the kitchen, but it behaves just as well on a nightstand where it can double as a smart alarm clock that’s also capable of turning on the lights when connected to products such as Philips Hue lighting. Hands-free voice control is present for playing music on Pandora, Spotify, iHeartRadio and TuneIn where it’s as simple as asking “Alexa, play love songs from the 90s” to help set the mood for date night.

With its connection to your smartphone via the downloadable Amazon Echo app on both Android and iOS, voice calling and messaging are present and accounted for. Whether it’s a quick call to Mom or sending a message to a friend that you’re running late, the Echo Dot offers instant contact without any extra charges. Weighing just 5.7 ounces, the Echo Dot offers thousands of additional uses with Amazon Skills without the size and price of its big brother. For buyers who want a quick and inexpensive way to introduce their home or office to a connected lifestyle, the Echo Dot is the best way to do so.  

The grandaddy of connected devices, Amazon’s 9.25-inch tall Echo has helped usher in a new era of smart home devices. With voice-interaction, the ability to control hundreds of connected devices, provide music playback from popular streaming services, set alarms, make to-do lists and play audiobooks, the Echo is a birthday or holiday gift wish-list favorite. The required Wi-Fi connection is easily managed with dual-band Wi-Fi support for both 2.4 and 5GHz networks. Weighing 37.5 ounces, the Echo has often been described as an all-black can of Pringles and it’s not entirely inaccurate.

Fortunately, the Echo is far more than a can of potato chips, thanks to its 360-degree omnidirectional audio speaker providing excellent room-filling sound. The biggest difference between the Echo and Echo Dot is the sound and the 2.5-inch woofer and 2.0-inch tweeter that help deliver deep bass and crisp high notes. These downward-firing speakers provide an immersive sound that eliminates the need for a separate speaker ala the Echo Dot, although audiophiles wanting maximum audio performance will opt for beefier third-party speakers.

As an Echo device, Amazon’s feature set is ever improving. Thousands of skills are added with new features and new possibilities arriving almost daily. Beyond controlling your lights, room temperature or ordering a pizza, the Echo is always listening for patterns in your requests or personal preferences, so it can provide better suggestions in the future. With software updates downloaded automatically, the Echo requires little ongoing maintenance, which allows users to focus on enjoying the device rather than upkeep.

Sign up for our daily deals newsletter


Disclosure: E-Commerce Content is independent of editorial content and we may receive compensation in connection with your purchase of products via links on this page.